Berliner Boersenzeitung - Georgian fighters in Ukraine wrestle with international humanitarian law

EUR -
AED 3.884622
AFN 71.845215
ALL 98.56526
AMD 409.224079
ANG 1.905628
AOA 965.621197
ARS 1056.318894
AUD 1.633339
AWG 1.906389
AZN 1.799806
BAM 1.964065
BBD 2.134884
BDT 126.351728
BGN 1.956737
BHD 0.398642
BIF 3122.028536
BMD 1.057636
BND 1.422847
BOB 7.305745
BRL 6.130005
BSD 1.057355
BTN 89.243286
BWP 14.514149
BYN 3.460262
BYR 20729.662984
BZD 2.131269
CAD 1.485153
CDF 3031.184243
CHF 0.938959
CLF 0.037313
CLP 1029.58763
CNY 7.644573
CNH 7.651958
COP 4740.059545
CRC 540.052286
CUC 1.057636
CUP 28.02735
CVE 110.730991
CZK 25.277288
DJF 188.283246
DKK 7.458786
DOP 63.947904
DZD 141.286364
EGP 52.196432
ERN 15.864538
ETB 131.064782
FJD 2.404319
FKP 0.83481
GBP 0.83347
GEL 2.882089
GGP 0.83481
GHS 16.996527
GIP 0.83481
GMD 75.091551
GNF 9112.486638
GTQ 8.165401
GYD 221.210926
HKD 8.233595
HNL 26.698482
HRK 7.544391
HTG 138.920831
HUF 406.658904
IDR 16814.083479
ILS 3.953755
IMP 0.83481
INR 89.295508
IQD 1385.129062
IRR 44531.757669
ISK 145.900769
JEP 0.83481
JMD 167.385201
JOD 0.749964
JPY 164.408966
KES 136.96951
KGS 91.48592
KHR 4294.64687
KMF 493.382838
KPW 951.871879
KRW 1475.254041
KWD 0.325202
KYD 0.881108
KZT 524.206025
LAK 23227.749724
LBP 94684.562614
LKR 308.909991
LRD 195.081889
LSL 19.353847
LTL 3.122924
LVL 0.639753
LYD 5.164759
MAD 10.560542
MDL 19.153604
MGA 4953.870876
MKD 61.730909
MMK 3435.160039
MNT 3593.846618
MOP 8.476271
MRU 42.0333
MUR 49.931234
MVR 16.351333
MWK 1833.424297
MXN 21.53867
MYR 4.728165
MZN 67.529792
NAD 19.353847
NGN 1766.685256
NIO 38.910252
NOK 11.706712
NPR 142.789579
NZD 1.80052
OMR 0.407214
PAB 1.05735
PEN 4.028955
PGK 4.189214
PHP 62.130289
PKR 293.676773
PLN 4.316474
PYG 8257.751231
QAR 3.854539
RON 4.976813
RSD 116.985418
RUB 105.579986
RWF 1451.716144
SAR 3.972546
SBD 8.866568
SCR 14.542056
SDG 636.163919
SEK 11.59133
SGD 1.417808
SHP 0.83481
SLE 24.00983
SLL 22178.100313
SOS 604.245714
SRD 37.394301
STD 21890.927079
SVC 9.251935
SYP 2657.341694
SZL 19.361571
THB 36.861252
TJS 11.271286
TMT 3.701726
TND 3.339469
TOP 2.47709
TRY 36.409859
TTD 7.179212
TWD 34.343573
TZS 2813.311443
UAH 43.588942
UGX 3880.329656
USD 1.057636
UYU 44.919247
UZS 13541.988977
VES 48.069456
VND 26853.374652
VUV 125.564655
WST 2.952487
XAF 658.732268
XAG 0.03451
XAU 0.000412
XCD 2.858314
XDR 0.796556
XOF 658.732268
XPF 119.331742
YER 264.25052
ZAR 19.237653
ZMK 9519.992964
ZMW 28.997029
ZWL 340.558318
  • RBGPF

    61.8400

    61.84

    +100%

  • RYCEF

    -0.3200

    6.79

    -4.71%

  • JRI

    -0.0300

    13.21

    -0.23%

  • SCS

    -0.1000

    13.27

    -0.75%

  • GSK

    -0.7200

    34.39

    -2.09%

  • CMSC

    -0.0600

    24.55

    -0.24%

  • RELX

    -0.1700

    45.95

    -0.37%

  • NGG

    0.2500

    62.37

    +0.4%

  • BTI

    0.0700

    35.49

    +0.2%

  • BCC

    -2.2000

    140.35

    -1.57%

  • RIO

    -0.1900

    60.43

    -0.31%

  • VOD

    -0.0700

    8.68

    -0.81%

  • BP

    0.4800

    29.05

    +1.65%

  • AZN

    -0.2500

    65.04

    -0.38%

  • BCE

    -0.3700

    26.84

    -1.38%

  • CMSD

    -0.0050

    24.725

    -0.02%

Georgian fighters in Ukraine wrestle with international humanitarian law
Georgian fighters in Ukraine wrestle with international humanitarian law / Photo: Sergei SUPINSKY - AFP/File

Georgian fighters in Ukraine wrestle with international humanitarian law

His forearm tattooed "Never forget, never forgive," the head of the Georgian National Legion Mamuka Mamulashvili listens intently to a presentation on the need for fighters in Ukraine to respect international humanitarian law.

Text size:

The event in the capital Kyiv is organised by a Swiss NGO called Geneva Call as part of its efforts to meet and provide guidance to a wide range of Ukrainian combatants.

As fighting rages, Geneva Call aims to impartially convey the rules of international combat to fighters who may have had little or no training, says Marie Lequin, head of its Eurasia region.

Held in an office centre with PowerPoint screens, the setting contrasts sharply with the battle-hardened appearance of the Georgian Legion fighters.

A fluent English speaker, Mamulashvili, who is Georgian, leads around 800 fighters from some 32 countries, fighting in southeastern Ukraine.

The Legion boasts that it recruits only volunteers with combat experience and so far has suffered injuries but no deaths.

Squadron leaders, mostly bearded and tattooed, flank him at the session in Kyiv.

Issues such as prisoners of war and rules on proportionality are covered. Other topics include whether to give relatives details on how a soldier died -- not necessarily -- and whether the conflict is legally defined as "international" -- it is.

Finally, the participants sign an undertaking to observe international norms, posing with their flag decorated with a red-eyed wolf.

"Today it's one step in a process we call humanitarian engagement... setting up a kind of dialogue with armed organisations to leverage some kind of change in policy and behaviour," Lequin tells AFP.

- 'Blurred lines' -

The treatment of civilians and human rights organisations prompts much discussion at the presentation.

Warning of potential "blurred lines" in the war, Lequin stresses that "it's important that humanitarian work, assistance, is separated from military operations".

But Mamulashvili counters that humanitarian organisations "should be more involved in the process and not stop at lectures".

He insists that his fighters "are getting the basic information about the Geneva Convention and different international laws that they should be aware of".

The Legion at the end of the session signed a commitment to protect the civilian population and allow access to humanitarian groups.

At the same time, he says the Legion carries out some humanitarian activities itself due to a lack of NGOs on the ground.

"We were transporting civilians from areas that have been shelled by Russians," he tells the session.

"We are doing it with cars that we bought with our own money and they're not armoured and it's quite dangerous for civilians."

Geneva Call says that if an armed group carries out a humanitarian aid distribution or evacuation, or accompanies humanitarian groups, it must ditch uniforms and not carry weapons while doing so.

"We don't carry arms with us when we distribute to volunteers the humanitarian aid," branch commander Taras Reshetylo tells AFP.

- 'Let's be models' -

Lequin warns that such well-intentioned actions can put civilians in danger by making them a potential target.

"It's confusing from a civilian perspective to understand if you are providing humanitarian assistance or if you are leading military operations to protect civilians," she tells Mamulashvili.

For NGOs, too, "it's very difficult to assess whether the military presence will turn us into a military objective or not," she adds.

Actions can be interpreted differently, or manipulated, Lequin tells AFP, adding that the conduct of war "will end up in court at some stage and it's important that we can document all this".

She urges Mamulashvili: "Let's be models and let's have the best practice."

- 'Grave violation' -

Some Ukrainian fighters in the war-torn east have used schools to accommodate soldiers and transported troops in yellow school buses, AFP journalists have seen -- making these potential targets.

"We have never used schools and I'm sure that Ukrainians are also not violating international law," Mamulashvili tells AFP.

But Russia, he claims, is "breaking all the rules" and he accuses it of using fake humanitarian aid organisations as covert means to bring in weapons.

Lequin says that this would be a "grave violation" and "perfidy".

Mamulashvili says the Legion, which carries out special operations, has units "spread everywhere on the front line".

"It is becoming heavier for us because Russia is not getting into contact fights anymore and they are only shooting artillery," he says, stressing Ukraine's need for more rocket systems to respond.

"Ukraine needs to protect its civilian population that is bombed daily and we have nothing to answer with," he warns.

(K.Müller--BBZ)