Berliner Boersenzeitung - Inside the 'living hell' of Cambodia's scam operations

EUR -
AED 4.295669
AFN 81.659805
ALL 97.59679
AMD 449.318813
ANG 2.093003
AOA 1072.451874
ARS 1475.644248
AUD 1.794058
AWG 2.10514
AZN 1.983214
BAM 1.949112
BBD 2.359903
BDT 142.594381
BGN 1.954148
BHD 0.440826
BIF 3482.281201
BMD 1.169522
BND 1.494286
BOB 8.076288
BRL 6.389332
BSD 1.168889
BTN 100.107506
BWP 15.605056
BYN 3.825008
BYR 22922.632738
BZD 2.347764
CAD 1.600134
CDF 3374.071364
CHF 0.933318
CLF 0.028812
CLP 1105.736529
CNY 8.391203
CNH 8.40049
COP 4728.868963
CRC 590.877604
CUC 1.169522
CUP 30.992335
CVE 109.890756
CZK 24.67598
DJF 208.146476
DKK 7.460604
DOP 70.129369
DZD 151.646348
EGP 58.102794
ERN 17.542831
ETB 162.211399
FJD 2.631132
FKP 0.857659
GBP 0.86313
GEL 3.169688
GGP 0.857659
GHS 12.184193
GIP 0.857659
GMD 83.619991
GNF 10137.475837
GTQ 8.983406
GYD 244.543456
HKD 9.18069
HNL 30.56313
HRK 7.53628
HTG 153.403634
HUF 399.99646
IDR 19032.334497
ILS 3.924764
IMP 0.857659
INR 100.31482
IQD 1531.146256
IRR 49266.117322
ISK 142.635147
JEP 0.857659
JMD 186.55467
JOD 0.829203
JPY 171.878229
KES 151.020046
KGS 102.274813
KHR 4692.97748
KMF 491.786276
KPW 1052.567626
KRW 1605.56683
KWD 0.357404
KYD 0.974099
KZT 607.326113
LAK 25179.817077
LBP 104723.56736
LKR 351.373364
LRD 234.357883
LSL 20.788303
LTL 3.453295
LVL 0.707432
LYD 6.313499
MAD 10.526351
MDL 19.782881
MGA 5162.330898
MKD 61.484377
MMK 2455.076978
MNT 4197.195447
MOP 9.451156
MRU 46.419912
MUR 52.757403
MVR 18.008227
MWK 2026.749695
MXN 21.884904
MYR 4.959987
MZN 74.80251
NAD 20.787772
NGN 1789.988932
NIO 43.013513
NOK 11.839768
NPR 160.173773
NZD 1.953501
OMR 0.449676
PAB 1.1688
PEN 4.167407
PGK 4.901308
PHP 66.212533
PKR 332.295336
PLN 4.245831
PYG 9315.275919
QAR 4.261188
RON 5.081113
RSD 117.18491
RUB 91.423841
RWF 1688.991301
SAR 4.386252
SBD 9.750217
SCR 16.501705
SDG 702.296742
SEK 11.172819
SGD 1.498561
SHP 0.919061
SLE 26.316673
SLL 24524.297511
SOS 668.019283
SRD 43.650656
STD 24206.745769
SVC 10.22717
SYP 15205.971824
SZL 20.779877
THB 38.148672
TJS 11.226754
TMT 4.105022
TND 3.408704
TOP 2.739135
TRY 46.809718
TTD 7.929858
TWD 34.070283
TZS 3081.915215
UAH 48.821633
UGX 4201.583321
USD 1.169522
UYU 46.930175
UZS 14816.540825
VES 130.147048
VND 30565.459521
VUV 138.967301
WST 3.205062
XAF 653.725086
XAG 0.032128
XAU 0.000355
XCD 3.160692
XDR 0.812384
XOF 653.730656
XPF 119.331742
YER 283.199244
ZAR 20.881174
ZMK 10527.103931
ZMW 28.313848
ZWL 376.585632
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

Inside the 'living hell' of Cambodia's scam operations
Inside the 'living hell' of Cambodia's scam operations / Photo: STR - AFP

Inside the 'living hell' of Cambodia's scam operations

Trafficked, beaten and locked up far from his family in China, Lu was one of thousands of people in Cambodia forced to operate online scams to line their captors' pockets.

Text size:

Covid shutdowns had left the builder out of work, so when he heard he could earn $2,000 a month on a construction project in Cambodia, he jumped at the chance.

But he soon realised he had been lured by a scamming gang to a compound in the seaside resort of Sihanoukville, along with hundreds of others.

There he was forced to work 12 to 16 hour shifts, trawling social media and dating apps on a hunt for victims to scam out of huge sums.

"Once I arrived it was too late to escape," Lu told AFP. "But as long as I was alive, I would keep trying."

People from countries around Asia -- including Vietnam, the Philippines, Thailand, Malaysia, China, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Bangladesh and India -- have been sucked into similar operations.

Some, like 34-year-old Lu, have made it out, though thousands of others are feared still trapped.

In August, the UN special rapporteur on the situation of human rights in Cambodia, Vitit Muntarbhorn, said the trafficking victims "were experiencing a living hell often resulting in torture and even death".

- Metal bars and barbed wire -

Sihanoukville was once a sleepy resort town, but it was transformed by a vast influx of Chinese investment.

Dozens of casinos sprang up in recent years, making it a hub for Chinese gamblers and drawing in international crime groups.

As travel restrictions bit during the pandemic, these groups shifted their focus.

Jeremy Douglas, of the United Nations Office for Drugs and Crime (UNODC), said "criminal groups moved casino businesses online, and some then did a pivot and added online and phone scams".

One gang member told AFP on condition of anonymity that the first people to fall prey to operations like his were Chinese nationals already in Cambodia.

Then gangs started trafficking people into the country.

Douglas of the UNODC said "thousands, and some have estimated possibly tens of thousands" of people have been ensnared.

To stop victims from escaping, compounds were installed with metal window bars and barbed wire.

"Once they arrived in the compound, they could not leave," the gang member said.

"People were beaten or tortured and sold if they refused to scam others."

Within Cambodia, some were sold on to other gangs, the source said. Those with good IT or English-language skills could be sold for up to $50,000.

- 'The real mafia' -

AFP interviewed four trafficking victims who said they too received lucrative job offers during the pandemic.

A 38-year-old Malaysian Chinese man called Roy described flying to Phnom Penh and being met by a woman in smart office wear who whisked him through immigration and into a car for the five-hour drive to Sihanoukville.

There, he was taken to a complex of apartment blocks a dozen or so storeys tall, housing a mix of accommodation and office rooms.

"It just looked like a normal office, with three rows of tables with monitors and keyboards, just like a cybercafe," Roy told AFP.

But he said "once you get in you know you're not doing customer service".

Roy and others like him had their passports taken away, and were instructed to set up fake profiles on apps and dating sites including TikTok, Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp.

Under the constant threat of violence, they would groom targets to pour money into crypto currency or other investment platforms.

Others were forced to build online "love" relationships with their targets and to scam them under the guise of needing help to pay debts off.

There are no reliable figures on how much money the gangs have netted from the scams, though the UN's Douglas said the numbers are "staggering".

It is not clear where the money ends up, he added, though criminal proceeds are often bundled together with online betting profits, with many of the scam compounds located near legal gambling businesses.

The gang member in Sihanoukville told AFP he did not know who he was ultimately working for.

"We don't know who is who," he said. "They are the real mafia."

- 'Shock, kick, shock' -

Forced scammers who resisted paid a high price. Construction worker Lu said he was "beaten quite often" because he was caught trying to escape.

Others said gang members used electric batons to inflict shocks, or forced workers into rooms too small to stand in, depriving them of water, food and light for hours.

"They ask someone to lie down and then kick them, like a dog," Roy said.

"Sometimes (they would) get an electric shock, kick and shock. They would get a five-minute to 10-minute beating."

Some, like Roy, were fortunate.

After being told he would have to buy his way out for $20,000, he was rescued after contacting Taiwanese victims group the Global Anti-Trafficking Organisation (GASO).

The group works with Cambodian officials to facilitate rescues and repatriate citizens.

Others have taken a more dramatic approach -- in August dozens of Vietnamese workers escaped a casino in southern Kandal province and swam across a river back to their homeland.

Attention on the issue has grown: in July the United States downgraded Cambodia in its annual human trafficking report.

After months of official denials, Prime Minister Hun Sen ordered a hunt for ringleaders and authorities launched a string of high-profile raids in August.

In September, police freed more than 1,000 foreigners from three Sihanoukville compounds.

At one site, a swoop netted nearly 9,000 mobile phones, 800 computers -- and chillingly, handcuffs and electric shock instruments.

It was during one such raid that Lu was released.

- Crackdown or relocation? -

Still, international observers and rights groups are sceptical of the depth of the government's crackdown.

Jacob Sims, International Justice Mission's Cambodia director, said the efforts need to go further than raids and rescues.

"Criminal accountability for the ringleaders of the transnational organised crime networks is absolutely essential if we hope to eradicate this issue," he said.

There are fears that rather than shutting down, the groups are simply relocating.

"Today it is an operation in Cambodia, but tomorrow a gang under pressure uproots and shifts to Myanmar, Laos or the Philippines -- and this has happened," the UN's Douglas said.

Back in Cambodia, those rescued by police, like Lu, face an uncertain future.

While he has evaded immigration detention, he told AFP he cannot afford to return to his wife and nine-year-old child in China.

A spokesperson for China's foreign ministry told AFP the government was working with Cambodia and other countries to fight transnational crime, and that it "resolutely upholds both the safety and legal rights and privileges of Chinese citizens abroad".

Lu said he had received no help from the Chinese embassy.

"The Chinese embassy only has one thing to say: 'Adults have to pay for their decisions,'" he said.

burs-rbu/pdw/ser

(A.Lehmann--BBZ)