Berliner Boersenzeitung - Fury as loophole in Spain rape law used to cut sentences

EUR -
AED 3.88255
AFN 71.983682
ALL 98.46873
AMD 411.080982
ANG 1.906107
AOA 962.964016
ARS 1055.490977
AUD 1.6322
AWG 1.897426
AZN 1.801534
BAM 1.962188
BBD 2.135441
BDT 126.384306
BGN 1.954789
BHD 0.39844
BIF 3123.510376
BMD 1.057062
BND 1.421903
BOB 7.308657
BRL 6.06944
BSD 1.057588
BTN 89.247225
BWP 14.429707
BYN 3.460835
BYR 20718.40665
BZD 2.131901
CAD 1.486836
CDF 3028.481617
CHF 0.936343
CLF 0.037411
CLP 1031.956073
CNY 7.652176
CNH 7.65423
COP 4653.956659
CRC 538.648628
CUC 1.057062
CUP 28.012131
CVE 110.618872
CZK 25.292524
DJF 188.33963
DKK 7.459783
DOP 63.726878
DZD 141.011865
EGP 52.221992
ERN 15.855923
ETB 130.926291
FJD 2.404128
FKP 0.834357
GBP 0.836675
GEL 2.89102
GGP 0.834357
GHS 16.869605
GIP 0.834357
GMD 75.050677
GNF 9114.156392
GTQ 8.171178
GYD 221.276241
HKD 8.228141
HNL 26.716985
HRK 7.540294
HTG 138.941048
HUF 407.222361
IDR 16733.707379
ILS 3.952829
IMP 0.834357
INR 89.216471
IQD 1385.538924
IRR 44494.364524
ISK 144.490814
JEP 0.834357
JMD 167.856978
JOD 0.749567
JPY 163.682281
KES 136.625315
KGS 91.439004
KHR 4273.833816
KMF 493.198497
KPW 951.355007
KRW 1474.209502
KWD 0.32512
KYD 0.881353
KZT 527.733193
LAK 23236.212443
LBP 94713.574895
LKR 308.137195
LRD 194.078205
LSL 19.155265
LTL 3.121228
LVL 0.639406
LYD 5.165525
MAD 10.589275
MDL 19.218207
MGA 4944.003062
MKD 61.533532
MMK 3433.294726
MNT 3591.895137
MOP 8.48037
MRU 42.167896
MUR 49.73442
MVR 16.331397
MWK 1834.036526
MXN 21.504955
MYR 4.736162
MZN 67.543037
NAD 19.154266
NGN 1767.638926
NIO 38.926737
NOK 11.694938
NPR 142.795561
NZD 1.803569
OMR 0.406993
PAB 1.057623
PEN 4.020289
PGK 4.254611
PHP 61.986622
PKR 293.80849
PLN 4.319629
PYG 8243.370729
QAR 3.857139
RON 4.976219
RSD 116.976467
RUB 105.966949
RWF 1452.889059
SAR 3.968438
SBD 8.86919
SCR 14.415999
SDG 635.83159
SEK 11.599681
SGD 1.419628
SHP 0.834357
SLE 23.888907
SLL 22166.057468
SOS 604.456543
SRD 37.425206
STD 21879.040171
SVC 9.254606
SYP 2655.898741
SZL 19.148161
THB 36.68214
TJS 11.253046
TMT 3.710286
TND 3.342984
TOP 2.475742
TRY 36.554206
TTD 7.18031
TWD 34.376737
TZS 2811.7834
UAH 43.8035
UGX 3883.644306
USD 1.057062
UYU 45.355092
UZS 13550.347868
VES 48.340782
VND 26865.219644
VUV 125.496473
WST 2.950883
XAF 658.087138
XAG 0.034006
XAU 0.000406
XCD 2.856762
XDR 0.804597
XOF 658.062156
XPF 119.331742
YER 264.133267
ZAR 19.074036
ZMK 9514.819499
ZMW 29.165404
ZWL 340.373392
  • AZN

    0.3300

    63.56

    +0.52%

  • SCS

    0.0750

    13.305

    +0.56%

  • BP

    0.4050

    29.385

    +1.38%

  • RBGPF

    1.6500

    61.84

    +2.67%

  • CMSC

    0.0750

    24.645

    +0.3%

  • GSK

    0.2300

    33.58

    +0.68%

  • RIO

    0.7750

    61.755

    +1.25%

  • NGG

    -0.0600

    62.69

    -0.1%

  • CMSD

    0.0100

    24.45

    +0.04%

  • RYCEF

    0.0400

    6.82

    +0.59%

  • BCC

    1.6900

    141.78

    +1.19%

  • BTI

    0.1740

    36.564

    +0.48%

  • JRI

    0.1000

    13.2

    +0.76%

  • BCE

    0.5100

    27.33

    +1.87%

  • RELX

    0.7100

    45.16

    +1.57%

  • VOD

    0.1550

    8.925

    +1.74%

Fury as loophole in Spain rape law used to cut sentences
Fury as loophole in Spain rape law used to cut sentences / Photo: GABRIEL BOUYS - AFP

Fury as loophole in Spain rape law used to cut sentences

A landmark law to fight sexual violence in Spain has come under fire over a loophole used by lawyers to get reduced sentences for some convicted offenders.

Text size:

The controversy erupted barely six weeks after the law came into force when it emerged that it had led to the jail sentences of some 15 offenders being cut.

One was a man who sexually assaulted his teenage step-daughter. His jail term was reduced from eight years to six.

A teacher who paid for sex with his pupils was released after his sentence was reduced. Four men have since walked out free, according to Spanish media reports.

Known as the "Only yes means yes" law, the new legislation reformed the criminal code to define all non-consensual sex as rape.

Although the new law raises the sentence for gang rape or chemical submission, it reduces both the maximum and minimum sentences in cases with no aggravating circumstances.

Hundreds of convicted offenders have applied to have their sentences revised since the law came into effect on October 7.

In Spain, a jail term can be retroactively modified if changes to the penal code benefits the convicted offender.

Until now, rape victims had needed to prove they were subjected to violence or intimidation.

Without that the offence was considered "sexual abuse" and carried lighter penalties than rape.

The legal change was driven by the notorious 2016 gang rape of an 18-year-old woman by five men at a bull-running festival in the northern city of Pamplona.

The men were initially convicted of sexual abuse and not rape, sparking mass nationwide protests.

The Supreme Court eventually overturned the verdict in 2019 and convicted all five of rape.

- 'Male chauvinist judges' -

With the lesser charge of "sexual abuse" dropped from the reformed criminal code and a much wider range of offences grouped under "sexual assault", a broader range of penalties was required to ensure proportionality.

Anyone previously convicted of sexual assault and handed the minimum sentence of eight years, can now benefit from the minimum being reduced to six.

The result has been a major backlash -- which has put the left-wing government of Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez on the back foot with Spain's legal watchdog hitting back at the flagship legislation as fundamentally flawed.

Equality Minister Irene Montero of the hard-left Podemos party, Sanchez's junior coalition partner, has accused those judges who have rubber-stamped such reductions of "breaking the law" on grounds of "male chauvinism".

Podemos lawmaker Javier Sanchez Serna went further, calling them "fascists in robes".

The General Council of the Judiciary -- which is responsible for ensuring the judiciary's independence -- lashed out at such "intolerable attacks", saying they had warned months ago the legislation could see convictions revised.

The Judges for Democracy association accused the ministry of "not foreseeing such (an undesired) consequence" saying it "in no way justified attacking judges".

- Wolf Pack to benefit? -

The biggest concern is that the changes could affect the sentences of the Pamplona gang rapists, the case which drove efforts to toughen the law.

Known as the "Wolf Pack", the men are serving 15-year sentences, with a lawyer confirming he will seek a reduction for one of them.

With just a year left until the next general elections, Sanchez came out in defence of the law, recalling its aim was to "give more guarantees to women in the face of any kind of sexual aggression".

"Let's wait to see what the courts and prosecutors say about this," he said on Wednesday, with the Supreme Court set to rule on certain cases within the coming month.

Even if the new law was modified, it would not undo the sentence revisions that have already been approved because legislation that toughens penalties is not applicable retroactively.

(K.Lüdke--BBZ)