Berliner Boersenzeitung - X's 'Community Notes': a model for Meta?

EUR -
AED 3.963234
AFN 76.086305
ALL 99.054872
AMD 422.000612
ANG 1.931653
AOA 989.452778
ARS 1157.60578
AUD 1.717208
AWG 1.944917
AZN 1.831215
BAM 1.955257
BBD 2.179725
BDT 131.19359
BGN 1.953835
BHD 0.406697
BIF 3159.342883
BMD 1.079011
BND 1.450004
BOB 7.460241
BRL 6.130724
BSD 1.079515
BTN 92.49276
BWP 14.81978
BYN 3.532836
BYR 21148.606728
BZD 2.168428
CAD 1.543077
CDF 3099.997488
CHF 0.953743
CLF 0.026614
CLP 1021.316118
CNY 7.844618
CNH 7.856481
COP 4476.275256
CRC 539.957654
CUC 1.079011
CUP 28.59378
CVE 110.703875
CZK 24.939059
DJF 191.761786
DKK 7.461886
DOP 68.247908
DZD 144.429186
EGP 54.570855
ERN 16.185158
ETB 140.383409
FJD 2.514688
FKP 0.832964
GBP 0.835429
GEL 2.977774
GGP 0.832964
GHS 16.722061
GIP 0.832964
GMD 77.689081
GNF 9339.915091
GTQ 8.330804
GYD 226.520284
HKD 8.396084
HNL 27.805753
HRK 7.533546
HTG 141.532358
HUF 402.08572
IDR 18058.212619
ILS 3.987554
IMP 0.832964
INR 92.372205
IQD 1413.503817
IRR 45426.343656
ISK 143.702923
JEP 0.832964
JMD 169.875217
JOD 0.765002
JPY 161.643332
KES 139.734056
KGS 93.510505
KHR 4273.960663
KMF 492.567633
KPW 971.091207
KRW 1588.163248
KWD 0.332669
KYD 0.899705
KZT 543.461694
LAK 23371.368448
LBP 96679.344745
LKR 319.622778
LRD 215.613286
LSL 19.939843
LTL 3.186038
LVL 0.652683
LYD 5.206271
MAD 10.39101
MDL 19.356794
MGA 5028.189316
MKD 61.493143
MMK 2265.151536
MNT 3767.661759
MOP 8.65302
MRU 42.960843
MUR 49.235367
MVR 16.632093
MWK 1873.162228
MXN 21.958921
MYR 4.794584
MZN 68.959579
NAD 19.939925
NGN 1663.985301
NIO 39.65908
NOK 11.298536
NPR 147.968736
NZD 1.889833
OMR 0.415397
PAB 1.079515
PEN 3.96482
PGK 4.355804
PHP 61.781971
PKR 302.392959
PLN 4.184802
PYG 8619.607841
QAR 3.928407
RON 4.975753
RSD 117.173023
RUB 91.177654
RWF 1527.878935
SAR 4.047645
SBD 9.075866
SCR 15.502996
SDG 647.406545
SEK 10.809269
SGD 1.450789
SHP 0.847933
SLE 24.574463
SLL 22626.31284
SOS 616.655953
SRD 39.485855
STD 22333.339816
SVC 9.445379
SYP 14029.138824
SZL 19.93974
THB 36.865658
TJS 11.761599
TMT 3.776537
TND 3.350873
TOP 2.527148
TRY 40.926131
TTD 7.325001
TWD 35.841277
TZS 2854.021747
UAH 44.678122
UGX 3944.923464
USD 1.079011
UYU 45.517368
UZS 13957.001874
VES 75.194961
VND 27660.435381
VUV 132.977879
WST 3.05119
XAF 655.78412
XAG 0.03207
XAU 0.000347
XCD 2.91608
XDR 0.813197
XOF 652.801749
XPF 119.331742
YER 265.437013
ZAR 19.967845
ZMK 9712.394484
ZMW 30.30801
ZWL 347.440956
  • CMSD

    0.0100

    22.82

    +0.04%

  • BCC

    0.8200

    98.91

    +0.83%

  • NGG

    0.1700

    65.78

    +0.26%

  • CMSC

    0.0400

    22.44

    +0.18%

  • BCE

    -0.1800

    22.78

    -0.79%

  • RIO

    0.1500

    60.23

    +0.25%

  • GSK

    -0.8700

    37.87

    -2.3%

  • RBGPF

    1.0000

    68

    +1.47%

  • SCS

    0.3600

    11.32

    +3.18%

  • BTI

    -0.2700

    41.1

    -0.66%

  • JRI

    0.0400

    12.98

    +0.31%

  • RYCEF

    0.3500

    10.05

    +3.48%

  • RELX

    0.2600

    50.67

    +0.51%

  • BP

    0.0200

    33.81

    +0.06%

  • AZN

    -0.9000

    72.6

    -1.24%

  • VOD

    -0.1000

    9.27

    -1.08%

X's 'Community Notes': a model for Meta?
X's 'Community Notes': a model for Meta? / Photo: EVARISTO SA - AFP/File

X's 'Community Notes': a model for Meta?

Meta chief Mark Zuckerberg said Tuesday that the group's platforms including Facebook and Instagram would in future imitate rival X's "Community Notes" feature rather than using professional fact-checkers.

Text size:

The feature "empower(s) their community to decide when posts are potentially misleading" thanks to "people across a diverse range of perspectives," Zuckerberg wrote in a blog post.

Facebook's fact-checking programme currently operates in 26 languages, partnering with more than 80 media organisations worldwide including AFP.

- What are Community Notes? -

When an X post has had a note appended, it is displayed to users with a small box titled "Readers added context".

Usually short and factual, expanding on or contradicting the original post, most published notes also include a link to relevant source material.

Introduced in January 2021 under the name Birdwatch, Community Notes were boosted by Elon Musk after he took over Twitter in late 2022 and renamed it X, and they now appear to users in 44 countries.

The social network "needs to become by far the most accurate source of information about the world", Musk posted at the time.

- Who writes Community Notes? -

Any willing X user can sign up to Community Notes.

Before writing notes of their own, they must first spend time rating other people's suggested notes, contributing to the process that decides whether they are published.

Even once allowed to write notes, users can lose the right if others consistently rate them unhelpful.

X underscores that voting on notes is not by simple majority.

Instead, the company looks for agreement between raters who have disagreed in the past -- a system it says "helps reduce one-sided ratings and helps to prevent manipulation".

This has not stopped charges from politicians that highly motivated groups carpet-bomb posts they dislike with notes, hoping at least one will get through.

- What impact have Community Notes had? -

There is little conclusive scientific analysis available of Community Notes' effectiveness.

One April 2024 paper published in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that a sample of notes on misinformation about Covid-19 vaccines "were accurate, cited moderate and high-credibility sources, and were attached to posts viewed hundreds of millions of times".

But the authors did not study the notes' impact on users.

Meanwhile in a survey of notes posted on November 5 -- US election day -- Cornell University digital harm researcher Alexios Mantzarlis found that just 29 percent of "fact-checkable" tweets for which notes were suggested in fact displayed a note rated as helpful.

"If Community Notes had an impact on election information quality on X, it was marginal at best," Mantzarlis wrote in an article for the Poynter Institute.

- What could come next? -

Some experts AFP spoke to were confident that Community Notes could improve information quality on Meta platforms.

"Community notes as such is a very, very effective tool in content moderation if applied in an equitable way, we can see that on Wikimedia or Wikipedia," said Katja Munoz of the Berlin-based think-tank DGAP.

Nevertheless, "the crowd may say something correct, but there can also be ill-intentioned people who are there to spread disinformation," said Christine Balaguer, a professor at France's Institut Mines-Telecom who studies the phenomenon.

Eliminating fact-checking could set Meta up for a clash with the European Union if it expands the model outside the United States.

The bloc's Digital Services Act encourages platforms to fight misinformation with tools including professional fact-checkers.

Zuckerberg's move "is a major shock" that "announces the clashes that the tech platforms are going to be having with EU regulation in general", Munoz said.

In his statement, Zuckerberg said fact-checking had been "a program intended to inform (that) too often became a tool to censor".

"Fact-checkers weren't censors," said Bill Adair, a professor of journalism and public policy at Duke University and co-founder of the International Fact-Checking Network (IFCN).

Those working with Meta "were signatories of a code of principles that requires they be transparent and nonpartisan", he noted.

IFCN chief Angie Drobnic Holan also defended fact-checkers' work, writing on X that Zuckerberg had faced "extreme political pressure from a new administration and its supporters".

Trump said Tuesday that Meta's move had "probably" been in response to his threats against the company and Zuckerberg.

(O.Joost--BBZ)