Berliner Boersenzeitung - Scottish and trans outrage as UK government blocks gender law

EUR -
AED 4.0291
AFN 74.562298
ALL 98.726555
AMD 424.402814
ANG 1.978808
AOA 996.588156
ARS 1068.703865
AUD 1.62925
AWG 1.974529
AZN 1.857318
BAM 1.954918
BBD 2.21695
BDT 131.210831
BGN 1.955748
BHD 0.413445
BIF 3185.959999
BMD 1.09696
BND 1.430764
BOB 7.587475
BRL 6.072993
BSD 1.09798
BTN 92.137131
BWP 14.55284
BYN 3.593396
BYR 21500.422468
BZD 2.213221
CAD 1.498502
CDF 3153.76127
CHF 0.940572
CLF 0.037119
CLP 1024.220535
CNY 7.747613
CNH 7.751829
COP 4641.326913
CRC 569.104454
CUC 1.09696
CUP 29.069449
CVE 110.213792
CZK 25.328676
DJF 195.527372
DKK 7.457344
DOP 66.045701
DZD 145.928782
EGP 53.310061
ERN 16.454405
ETB 133.297622
FJD 2.438268
FKP 0.8354
GBP 0.838126
GEL 2.983486
GGP 0.8354
GHS 17.469883
GIP 0.8354
GMD 74.046307
GNF 9476.078912
GTQ 8.493325
GYD 229.613317
HKD 8.528444
HNL 27.42422
HRK 7.458245
HTG 144.696176
HUF 399.353877
IDR 17115.872029
ILS 4.128684
IMP 0.8354
INR 92.060585
IQD 1437.018032
IRR 46182.029823
ISK 148.693148
JEP 0.8354
JMD 173.3847
JOD 0.777413
JPY 162.57446
KES 141.661813
KGS 93.308651
KHR 4452.728215
KMF 492.782048
KPW 987.263675
KRW 1472.26336
KWD 0.336296
KYD 0.915092
KZT 535.171106
LAK 24244.961731
LBP 98329.007105
LKR 321.710262
LRD 211.924433
LSL 19.174841
LTL 3.239038
LVL 0.66354
LYD 5.251512
MAD 10.758435
MDL 19.325373
MGA 5037.521698
MKD 61.591945
MMK 3562.884362
MNT 3727.471152
MOP 8.792995
MRU 43.468426
MUR 50.405271
MVR 16.843845
MWK 1903.945962
MXN 21.243465
MYR 4.698274
MZN 70.041235
NAD 19.174841
NGN 1777.931352
NIO 40.409935
NOK 11.769266
NPR 147.406449
NZD 1.799728
OMR 0.422332
PAB 1.098
PEN 4.090181
PGK 4.314818
PHP 62.562391
PKR 304.623595
PLN 4.302013
PYG 8559.944843
QAR 3.993484
RON 4.976795
RSD 117.021513
RUB 106.130429
RWF 1498.762656
SAR 4.118557
SBD 9.104032
SCR 14.932874
SDG 659.823271
SEK 11.333767
SGD 1.429893
SHP 0.8354
SLE 25.062585
SLL 23002.703999
SOS 627.491294
SRD 34.775233
STD 22704.864077
SVC 9.607711
SYP 2756.145668
SZL 19.167919
THB 36.612191
TJS 11.683032
TMT 3.839361
TND 3.367236
TOP 2.569191
TRY 37.588665
TTD 7.443677
TWD 35.286254
TZS 2989.216567
UAH 45.211945
UGX 4035.125199
USD 1.09696
UYU 45.389532
UZS 14041.092595
VEF 3973796.423614
VES 40.617988
VND 27234.782593
VUV 130.233334
WST 3.068706
XAF 655.628475
XAG 0.035906
XAU 0.000419
XCD 2.96459
XDR 0.816798
XOF 655.646396
XPF 119.331742
YER 274.596631
ZAR 19.296904
ZMK 9873.956393
ZMW 29.123009
ZWL 353.220779
  • JRI

    -0.0200

    13.16

    -0.15%

  • SCS

    -0.1700

    12.78

    -1.33%

  • BCC

    0.7500

    142.02

    +0.53%

  • CMSC

    0.0700

    24.64

    +0.28%

  • BCE

    -0.0200

    33.51

    -0.06%

  • RIO

    -2.9600

    66.66

    -4.44%

  • NGG

    0.4200

    65.9

    +0.64%

  • GSK

    -0.6100

    38.02

    -1.6%

  • BTI

    0.0200

    35.22

    +0.06%

  • AZN

    0.0000

    76.87

    0%

  • BP

    -1.1100

    32.03

    -3.47%

  • CMSD

    0.0610

    24.851

    +0.25%

  • RBGPF

    59.3300

    59.33

    +100%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0600

    6.91

    -0.87%

  • RELX

    0.6000

    46.64

    +1.29%

  • VOD

    -0.0300

    9.66

    -0.31%

Scottish and trans outrage as UK government blocks gender law
Scottish and trans outrage as UK government blocks gender law / Photo: JESSICA TAYLOR - UK PARLIAMENT/AFP

Scottish and trans outrage as UK government blocks gender law

The UK government denied Tuesday it was dismantling Scottish self-rule after exercising an unprecedented veto to block a new law passed already by the Edinburgh parliament.

Text size:

The legislation would make it easier for people to self-identify as transgender in Scotland, without the need for a medical diagnosis, and lower the qualifying age from 18 to 16.

The standoff has ratcheted up London's tense relations with the Scottish government, less than two months after Nicola Sturgeon's Scottish National Party (SNP) saw its efforts to hold a new independence referendum stymied by the UK Supreme Court.

The Scottish parliament, set up in 1999, sets policy in Scotland in areas such as health and education, with the UK government in London retaining powers to determine issues affecting all four nations of the United Kingdom, such as defence and foreign affairs.

Interviewed on BBC TV, First Minister Sturgeon called the UK government's block a "direct attack on the institution of the Scottish parliament", and also an attack on a "stigmatised, vulnerable, often marginalised group".

She vowed to fight it in the courts. But in London the Conservative government's secretary of state for Scotland, Alister Jack, said the Scottish measure would have "a serious adverse impact" on UK-wide equality legislation.

"The government shares the concerns of many members of the public and civic society groups regarding the potential impact of the bill on women and girls," he told parliament.

"This is absolutely not about the United Kingdom government being able to veto Scottish Parliament legislation whenever it chooses, as some have implied," he added.

"The power can only be exercised on specific grounds, and the fact that this is the first time it has been necessary to exercise the power in almost 25 years of devolution emphasises that it is not a power to be used lightly."

Prime Minister Rishi Sunak's office denied the UK government was split on the emotive issue, after Education Secretary Gillian Keegan noted that when she was 16, she had already left school and was looking after herself.

Asked if 16 was too young to change gender, she told Sky News: "No I don't, actually.

"I was working at 16, I was paying tax at 16, I was making decisions for myself at 16.

"But it's not really about what I think, it's how we make sure we get that right balance of supporting children, but also making sure that what they're getting taught in schools is age-appropriate," Keegan added.

- 'Basic decency' -

Debate about trans rights has been turning increasingly acrimonious in Britain, with some women including "Harry Potter" author J.K. Rowling receiving online death threats for insisting on the equal rights of biological women.

But other countries including Belgium, Denmark and Ireland have already introduced gender self-identification, and the move is backed by World Health Organization guidance, according to the SNP.

Outside Sunak's Downing Street office in London, about a dozen people led by 25-year-old trans rights campaigner Owen Hurcum staged a vocal protest.

"It's quite frankly ridiculous that this transphobic Conservative government overturned devolution, democracy and basic decency to target a small group of people who just want even the semblance of something resembling dignity," Hurcum told AFP.

Sturgeon said Sunak's Conservatives were bent on "culture war" at the expense of transgender people, and rejected one argument that predatory men could exploit the legislation to gain access to women-only spaces.

The SNP has in turn exploited the row to build its case for Scottish independence from an overbearing UK.

But Sturgeon was forced to downplay signs of party discord over her declared intent to turn the UK's next general into a de-facto vote on separation.

After the Supreme Court blocked a second plebiscite without London's approval, senior voices in the SNP are openly unhappy with Sturgeon's tactics and fear the election gambit could backfire by stoking support for other parties.

"It's called internal democracy," Sturgeon said, insisting the SNP was having a "proper, full discussion" in the buildup to a special party conference on March 19.

(Y.Yildiz--BBZ)