Berliner Boersenzeitung - Top consultancy undermining climate change fight: whistleblowers

EUR -
AED 4.31222
AFN 81.610467
ALL 97.926788
AMD 450.678394
ANG 2.10136
AOA 1076.733652
ARS 1470.683715
AUD 1.796043
AWG 2.113545
AZN 1.970703
BAM 1.962287
BBD 2.370637
BDT 143.123136
BGN 1.959133
BHD 0.442591
BIF 3453.2976
BMD 1.174192
BND 1.504072
BOB 8.112819
BRL 6.556453
BSD 1.174382
BTN 100.566452
BWP 15.686858
BYN 3.842402
BYR 23014.156053
BZD 2.358396
CAD 1.607005
CDF 3388.717147
CHF 0.930447
CLF 0.029051
CLP 1114.82449
CNY 8.430989
CNH 8.432522
COP 4724.066497
CRC 592.157551
CUC 1.174192
CUP 31.116078
CVE 110.961364
CZK 24.646464
DJF 208.67735
DKK 7.46136
DOP 70.627298
DZD 152.323179
EGP 58.244131
ERN 17.612875
ETB 159.810659
FJD 2.638115
FKP 0.865106
GBP 0.863289
GEL 3.18274
GGP 0.865106
GHS 12.208336
GIP 0.865106
GMD 83.954391
GNF 10163.803033
GTQ 9.023831
GYD 245.531677
HKD 9.217234
HNL 30.940601
HRK 7.539599
HTG 154.099421
HUF 399.60031
IDR 19078.265691
ILS 3.901903
IMP 0.865106
INR 100.638732
IQD 1538.191042
IRR 49462.822344
ISK 143.380424
JEP 0.865106
JMD 187.690466
JOD 0.832482
JPY 171.453701
KES 152.020478
KGS 102.683116
KHR 4721.424736
KMF 494.334346
KPW 1056.746656
KRW 1610.814848
KWD 0.358516
KYD 0.978435
KZT 608.882841
LAK 25292.0883
LBP 105207.570841
LKR 352.976869
LRD 235.427965
LSL 20.888985
LTL 3.467083
LVL 0.710257
LYD 6.3409
MAD 10.573555
MDL 19.900788
MGA 5201.66942
MKD 61.602502
MMK 2465.224011
MNT 4213.656146
MOP 9.493483
MRU 46.621244
MUR 53.179002
MVR 18.085411
MWK 2038.985326
MXN 21.854325
MYR 4.984417
MZN 75.101526
NAD 20.888351
NGN 1800.751839
NIO 43.151831
NOK 11.835616
NPR 160.905922
NZD 1.956773
OMR 0.451475
PAB 1.174081
PEN 4.161926
PGK 4.85884
PHP 66.453401
PKR 333.764196
PLN 4.24306
PYG 9100.082997
QAR 4.274765
RON 5.076851
RSD 117.152592
RUB 91.8245
RWF 1683.790805
SAR 4.404026
SBD 9.789147
SCR 16.569009
SDG 705.035344
SEK 11.146371
SGD 1.502173
SHP 0.92273
SLE 26.426815
SLL 24622.2158
SOS 671.048817
SRD 43.739222
STD 24303.396168
SVC 10.27296
SYP 15266.992119
SZL 20.889157
THB 38.302167
TJS 11.359452
TMT 4.121413
TND 3.40881
TOP 2.750072
TRY 47.039407
TTD 7.972355
TWD 34.310701
TZS 3085.2346
UAH 49.075333
UGX 4214.933701
USD 1.174192
UYU 47.497015
UZS 14906.362385
VES 131.847391
VND 30692.195157
VUV 140.085669
WST 3.232974
XAF 658.132651
XAG 0.032269
XAU 0.000354
XCD 3.173312
XDR 0.817336
XOF 655.786187
XPF 119.331742
YER 283.978432
ZAR 20.912899
ZMK 10569.127304
ZMW 28.560415
ZWL 378.089228
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

Top consultancy undermining climate change fight: whistleblowers
Top consultancy undermining climate change fight: whistleblowers / Photo: Lionel BONAVENTURE - AFP

Top consultancy undermining climate change fight: whistleblowers

The world's top management consultancy McKinsey & Company is using its position as a key advisor to the UN's COP28 climate talks to push the interests of its big oil and gas clients, undermining efforts to end the use of the fossil fuels driving global warming, according to multiple sources and leaked documents.

Text size:

Behind closed doors, the US-based firm has proposed future energy scenarios to the agenda setters of the summit that are at odds with the climate goals it publicly espouses, an AFP investigation has found.

An "energy transition narrative" drafted by the firm and obtained by AFP only reduces oil use by 50 percent by 2050, and calls for trillions in new oil and gas investment per year from now until then.

McKinsey -- whose big oil clients range from America's ExxonMobil to Saudi Arabia's state-run Aramco -- is one of several consultancies giving free advice to the United Arab Emirates as it hosts the critical negotiations, which start on November 30.

Controversially, the talks are being presided over by Sultan Al Jaber, head of the Emirati state oil firm ADNOC.

With scientists saying 2023 is certain to be the hottest year on record, and greenhouse gas emissions headed for unprecedented levels, McKinsey is "vocally and brazenly calling for lower levels of ambition on oil phase-out at the highest levels within the COP28 presidency," said a source who was in the room on confidential discussions with the summit hosts.

McKinsey responded insisting that "sustainability is a mission-critical priority" and that it is committed to helping clients decarbonise.

"We are proud to be supporting COP28 by providing strategic insight and analysis, and sectoral and technical expertise," it told AFP.

- 'Written by oil industry for oil industry' -

Some of McKinsey's rival consultancies operating in Dubai have worked in the spirit of finding genuine climate solutions, according to three sources who have taken part in high-level preparatory meetings, who asked not to be named as the proceedings were confidential.

"But it was very clear from an early stage that McKinsey had a conflict of interest," said a source who took part in COP28 presidency discussions.

"They would give advice at the highest levels that was not in the best interest of the COP president as the leader of a multilateral climate agreement, but in the best interest of the COP president as the CEO of one of the region's biggest oil and gas companies."

Confidential documents seen by AFP back this up.

The McKinsey energy scenario for the COP28 presidency "reads as if it was written by the oil industry for the oil industry", said Kingsmill Bond, a top equity expert who analysed it.

"This is clearly not a credible pathway to net zero," Bond, a senior principal at the Rocky Mountain Institute think tank, told AFP.

A COP28 spokesman confirmed to AFP that "McKinsey supports COP28 through providing insights and analysis on a pro bono basis." But to say the firm presented scenarios incompatible with global climate targets "is just incorrect", he added.

- At odds with net zero -

Structured like a law firm, McKinsey employs some 35,000 people worldwide, including 2,500 partners and 700 semi-autonomous senior partners, with revenue last year reported at about $15 billion.

The 2015 Paris Agreement calls on nations to cap warming at 1.5 degrees Celsius, and the UN's scientific advisory body has said the world economy must be carbon-neutral by 2050 to stay below that.

But analysts said the pathway McKinsey suggested to Jaber for the COP talks would allow fossil fuel firms to continue to pump way too much oil and gas to hit "net zero".

"On average, 40-50 MMb/d (millions of barrels per day) of oil is still expected to be utilized in 2050," compared to about 100 MMb/d today, McKinsey's narrative said.

That is twice the amount allowed in the International Energy Agency (IEA) net zero roadmap, said Jim Williams of the University of San Francisco, a top modeller of decarbonisation trajectories.

The IEA says CO2-removal technologies must scale up 100,000-fold by 2050 to stay on track for a net zero world -- a mind-boggling challenge with no guarantee of success.

But the McKinsey scenario would likely require at least double that, experts said.

"It must involve either far more massive levels of negative emissions technologies" that pull CO2 out of the air, "or an even faster phase out of coal and gas", said former BP geologist Mike Coffin, head of the Oil, Gas and Mining team at Carbon Tracker.

- Oil demand to peak -

McKinsey's draft for COP28 says $2.7 trillion a year in new investment will have to be sunk into oil and gas until mid-century, clashing head-on with the IEA net-zero blueprint.

"Even with the current situation and no additional climate policies, we expect that global oil demand will peak in this decade," said IEA Executive Director Fatih Birol.

Many oil and gas majors -- buoyed by high prices and profits in the wake of the war in Ukraine -- have backed off commitments to transition to renewables or, in some cases, doubled down on their core business.

"We will stay anchored in what we know we're good at," ExxonMobil CEO Darren Woods told McKinsey in an interview published on the firm's website in September, explaining why his company steered clear of wind and solar power.

- Internal revolt -

In 2021, McKinsey's work for fossil fuel clients sparked a rebellion within its own ranks.

More than 1,100 of the firm's employees signed an internal letter seen by AFP warning that "there is significant risk to McKinsey and our values from pursuing the current course."

"Our inaction on (or perhaps assistance with) client emissions poses serious risk to our reputation" and "our client relationships", they wrote.

"We have been telling the world to be bold and align to a 1.5C emissions pathway; it is long overdue that we take our own advice."

McKinsey told AFP that the firm has committed to help clients reach the 2050 net zero target and this means engaging with "high-emitting sectors".

"Walking away from these sectors would do nothing to solve the climate challenge," it added.

- 'We need consultancies' -

As global warming accelerates, many companies are hiring consultancies to prepare for climate-related risks and opportunities.

"We do need the consultancies to help because we've got to get going and move very quickly," said Bob Ward of the Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment at the London School of Economics.

"But it's essential that they actively work for the transition rather than trying to slow it down because of the vested interests of incumbents, such as the fossil fuel industry."

The big players -- McKinsey, Boston Consulting Group and Bain -- hire top graduates on six-figure salaries to draw up plans for clients.

A 2022 McKinsey document promoting private carbon markets seen by AFP identified several of its important clients, including oil firms Chevron and BP, power firm Drax, and mining giant Rio Tinto.

The world's largest oil company, Aramco, declined to comment when asked by AFP about its relationship to the firm.

McKinsey says it has helped healthcare industry clients develop solar capacity, wind energy providers to become more competitive, and at least one developing country to source more electricity with renewables, but does not name the clients.

"If we want to ensure a managed decline of fossil fuel production, we can't do so if those helping (companies) make money from fossil fuel production continue to have a seat around the table," Pascoe Sabido, a researcher at the Corporate Europe Observatory think tank, told AFP.

He said there was a regulatory "blind spot" over consultancies' role in handling the climate crisis.

"The lobbying and the fixing that happens under the radar... is much more dangerous because there's much less accountability."

- 'Gas and oil consultancy' -

McKinsey has weathered tough headlines over recent years.

It was forced to pay out hundreds of millions of dollars over the past two years to settle lawsuits after being accused of fuelling an opioid overdose epidemic by advising drug companies. McKinsey denied any wrongdoing.

Multiple investigations have shown that oil and gas giants were aware of the likely trajectory and impacts of global warming as early as the 1970s based on research by their own scientists, while at the same time sowing doubt on climate science that had come to the same conclusion.

McKinsey is "capable of doing good work helping clients navigate the energy transition, but that work pales in comparison to what it is doing for oil and gas," said one former McKinsey consultant, who asked not to be named due to a non-disclosure agreement.

"They serve the world's largest polluters," he argued. "The firm is best understood as possibly the most powerful oil and gas consulting firm on the planet posturing as a sustainability firm, advising polluting clients on any opportunity to preserve the status quo."

(Y.Berger--BBZ)