Berliner Boersenzeitung - The centuries-old mines stirring Japan-South Korea tensions

EUR -
AED 4.291877
AFN 80.86012
ALL 97.598394
AMD 448.394165
ANG 2.091145
AOA 1071.500118
ARS 1470.822999
AUD 1.78063
AWG 2.103271
AZN 1.973932
BAM 1.949775
BBD 2.360804
BDT 142.180622
BGN 1.951359
BHD 0.440471
BIF 3483.73429
BMD 1.168484
BND 1.495279
BOB 8.108941
BRL 6.480646
BSD 1.169187
BTN 100.127578
BWP 15.579854
BYN 3.826375
BYR 22902.287545
BZD 2.348642
CAD 1.598924
CDF 3372.244724
CHF 0.931515
CLF 0.028918
CLP 1109.685633
CNY 8.390007
CNH 8.391135
COP 4701.500773
CRC 589.677731
CUC 1.168484
CUP 30.964828
CVE 109.9253
CZK 24.640989
DJF 208.206584
DKK 7.46132
DOP 70.272837
DZD 151.643807
EGP 57.887753
ERN 17.527261
ETB 161.734695
FJD 2.623483
FKP 0.860195
GBP 0.861751
GEL 3.16645
GGP 0.860195
GHS 12.189332
GIP 0.860195
GMD 83.538408
GNF 10145.647121
GTQ 8.982242
GYD 244.624043
HKD 9.172577
HNL 30.586479
HRK 7.538474
HTG 153.405933
HUF 398.681499
IDR 18979.569712
ILS 3.87318
IMP 0.860195
INR 100.188335
IQD 1531.666723
IRR 49222.390939
ISK 142.800154
JEP 0.860195
JMD 186.852573
JOD 0.828496
JPY 171.093525
KES 151.423705
KGS 102.183881
KHR 4689.508112
KMF 491.931282
KPW 1051.623909
KRW 1604.98325
KWD 0.357334
KYD 0.974389
KZT 606.565543
LAK 25192.149234
LBP 104762.4548
LKR 351.234587
LRD 234.42556
LSL 20.738413
LTL 3.450229
LVL 0.706805
LYD 6.31648
MAD 10.511018
MDL 19.782865
MGA 5164.041671
MKD 61.564202
MMK 2453.292929
MNT 4191.124617
MOP 9.454084
MRU 46.453446
MUR 52.756881
MVR 17.995182
MWK 2027.434662
MXN 21.812291
MYR 4.963133
MZN 74.736756
NAD 20.738413
NGN 1786.600268
NIO 43.027034
NOK 11.79549
NPR 160.203925
NZD 1.944362
OMR 0.449308
PAB 1.169187
PEN 4.143097
PGK 4.906837
PHP 66.076602
PKR 332.644336
PLN 4.252697
PYG 9061.995906
QAR 4.263126
RON 5.081276
RSD 117.131165
RUB 91.039736
RWF 1689.479039
SAR 4.382259
SBD 9.741563
SCR 16.489668
SDG 701.672719
SEK 11.14562
SGD 1.496378
SHP 0.918245
SLE 26.285753
SLL 24502.530745
SOS 668.234968
SRD 43.663936
STD 24185.260849
SVC 10.230385
SYP 15192.548431
SZL 20.743896
THB 38.165045
TJS 11.312242
TMT 4.101379
TND 3.411757
TOP 2.736701
TRY 46.813579
TTD 7.939465
TWD 34.176172
TZS 3073.113303
UAH 48.936672
UGX 4190.051572
USD 1.168484
UYU 47.503202
UZS 14794.281544
VES 132.747147
VND 30514.376943
VUV 139.568249
WST 3.21449
XAF 653.936155
XAG 0.031816
XAU 0.000352
XCD 3.157887
XDR 0.81258
XOF 653.936155
XPF 119.331742
YER 282.597698
ZAR 20.729363
ZMK 10517.750801
ZMW 27.389359
ZWL 376.25139
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

The centuries-old mines stirring Japan-South Korea tensions
The centuries-old mines stirring Japan-South Korea tensions / Photo: Charly TRIBALLEAU - AFP

The centuries-old mines stirring Japan-South Korea tensions

Under a split-top mountain on the Japanese island of Sado lies a network of centuries-old mines that have sparked a new diplomatic row with South Korea.

Text size:

Some of the gold and silver mines of Sado, off Japan's west coast, are believed to have started operating as early as the 12th century and produced until after World War II.

Japan believes that lengthy history and the artisanal mining techniques used there at a time when European mines had turned to mechanisation merit recognition on UNESCO's World Heritage List.

But in Seoul, the focus is on what isn't mentioned in the bid: the use of conscripted Korean labour during the Second World War, when Japan occupied the Korean peninsula.

Japan is seeking recognition of three sites -- the Nishimikawa gold mine, the Tsurushi silver mine, and the Aikawa gold and silver mines -- for the period between 1603 and 1867.

Officials and supporters of the bid say that era was when the mines were the world's most productive and mining was done by hand.

But it also stops short of the period when conscripted Koreans toiled in conditions that even some backers of the UNESCO bid call "extremely harsh".

The World Heritage effort has been years in the making, inspired in part by the successful recognition of a silver mine in western Japan's Shimane region.

Ryo Usami, from Sado city's World Heritage Promotion section, said locals hoped the recognition would highlight the mine's contributions to the unique culture and history of the island.

"Many people migrated to Sado to mine gold and silver... They came from all over Japan and brought their local cultures," Usami told AFP.

"Sado's history is basically the history of these gold mines, and its culture formed in part thanks to the mining operations. That's what Sado city wants to preserve."

- 'Discrimination did exist' -

Production at the sites petered out by the 1960s, when mine operator Mitsubishi Materials began accepting tourists.

In the 1970s, animatronic robots were installed in some mining tunnels to give a sense of what life there was like.

The eerie, rundown figures remain, their heads swivelling side-to-side and arms mechanically swinging pickaxes up and down in a forlorn fashion.

Groups of domestic tourists file through the frigid tunnels and read panels that explain the history of Sado's mining industry.

The panels note that Edo-era miners were often homeless or unregistered people who were captured and forced to work, and that child labour was used at times.

But there is little to testify that an estimated 1,500 Koreans worked at the sites during World War II.

Their status is disputed, with some arguing around two-thirds signed contracts voluntarily, while the remainder were conscripted during war-time mobilisation.

"The working conditions were extremely harsh, nevertheless the pay was very high, that's why lots of people, including many Japanese, applied," said Koichiro Matsuura, a former UNESCO director-general who is backing Sado's bid.

Others argue the recruitment conditions effectively amounted to forced labour, and that Korean workers faced significantly harsher conditions than their Japanese counterparts.

"Discrimination did exist," said Toyomi Asano, a professor of history of Japanese politics at Tokyo's Waseda University.

"Their working conditions were very bad and dangerous. The most dangerous jobs were allocated to them."

- 'A part of our history' -

Wartime issues like forced labour have soured ties between Japan and South Korea, and Seoul has formed a task force to push back against the UNESCO bid.

After the bid was announced, the government summoned Tokyo's ambassador and issued a statement saying it "strongly regrets" the nomination and "sternly urges Japan to stop its attempt".

The issue of forced labour affects other Japanese heritage sites, including the "Sites of the Meiji Industrial Revolution" inscribed in 2015.

UNESCO last year demanded an information centre for the sites properly explain that a "large number of Koreans and others (were) brought against their will and forced to work under harsh conditions".

Matsuura believes Japan must "avoid making the same mistake" at Sado.

"We must say in a more concrete and more honest manner how the Korean workers lived and worked at the Sado gold mines."

It's a view shared by some visitors, including 79-year-old Hideji Yamagami.

"Of course they should (explain), I didn't know about it at all," he told AFP after a trip through the Aikawa site.

"I thought it was Japanese who had done all the hard work."

Asano hopes UNESCO will insist the full history of Sado's mines is on display if the site gets World Heritage status, and believes Japan "should not fear" recognising a part of its history.

"Every nation has its dark history, those nations who are completely exempt do not exist."

(Y.Berger--BBZ)