Berliner Boersenzeitung - Energy majors exaggerating green performance: analysis

EUR -
AED 4.021503
AFN 73.974597
ALL 98.722789
AMD 422.669128
ANG 1.970756
AOA 999.073261
ARS 1065.84545
AUD 1.62179
AWG 1.971313
AZN 1.865626
BAM 1.955657
BBD 2.207839
BDT 130.670456
BGN 1.955539
BHD 0.41227
BIF 3225.864382
BMD 1.09487
BND 1.428296
BOB 7.583446
BRL 6.144196
BSD 1.09352
BTN 91.900888
BWP 14.51194
BYN 3.578539
BYR 21459.452596
BZD 2.204139
CAD 1.507253
CDF 3151.036344
CHF 0.938544
CLF 0.03677
CLP 1018.515607
CNY 7.736575
CNH 7.74406
COP 4594.964383
CRC 564.858743
CUC 1.09487
CUP 29.014056
CVE 110.256947
CZK 25.320626
DJF 194.715778
DKK 7.468879
DOP 65.835191
DZD 145.736004
EGP 53.12012
ERN 16.42305
ETB 130.945336
FJD 2.431492
FKP 0.837761
GBP 0.837761
GEL 2.972616
GGP 0.837761
GHS 17.446726
GIP 0.837761
GMD 75.002813
GNF 9434.310915
GTQ 8.455382
GYD 228.77329
HKD 8.507035
HNL 27.199013
HRK 7.542593
HTG 144.069477
HUF 401.69729
IDR 17046.195734
ILS 4.116241
IMP 0.837761
INR 92.119463
IQD 1432.49537
IRR 46096.769633
ISK 149.614412
JEP 0.837761
JMD 173.117355
JOD 0.77572
JPY 163.305383
KES 141.049698
KGS 93.615547
KHR 4442.675506
KMF 492.148233
KPW 985.383411
KRW 1477.330449
KWD 0.335611
KYD 0.911233
KZT 529.441329
LAK 23977.248695
LBP 97920.747843
LKR 320.076622
LRD 211.044585
LSL 19.108004
LTL 3.232867
LVL 0.662276
LYD 5.234618
MAD 10.723017
MDL 19.29959
MGA 5024.632999
MKD 61.6055
MMK 3556.09515
MNT 3720.368742
MOP 8.752161
MRU 43.289838
MUR 50.477604
MVR 16.806669
MWK 1896.161504
MXN 21.106947
MYR 4.69426
MZN 69.966278
NAD 19.108004
NGN 1795.587226
NIO 40.237061
NOK 11.710296
NPR 147.04126
NZD 1.792225
OMR 0.421471
PAB 1.09352
PEN 4.073302
PGK 4.300686
PHP 62.659822
PKR 303.53693
PLN 4.294386
PYG 8534.376647
QAR 3.986609
RON 4.980021
RSD 117.185076
RUB 104.753149
RWF 1472.392456
SAR 4.111472
SBD 9.086684
SCR 14.892612
SDG 658.568348
SEK 11.361252
SGD 1.429029
SHP 0.837761
SLE 25.014827
SLL 22958.881115
SOS 624.954353
SRD 34.97727
STD 22661.599096
SVC 9.568301
SYP 2750.894202
SZL 19.101605
THB 36.289509
TJS 11.656449
TMT 3.842994
TND 3.366254
TOP 2.564299
TRY 37.569922
TTD 7.422458
TWD 35.231608
TZS 2979.682363
UAH 45.028211
UGX 4018.706473
USD 1.09487
UYU 45.72666
UZS 13961.980213
VEF 3966224.203526
VES 42.519585
VND 27174.674155
VUV 129.985201
WST 3.069587
XAF 655.909092
XAG 0.034703
XAU 0.000412
XCD 2.958941
XDR 0.813441
XOF 655.909092
XPF 119.331742
YER 274.10111
ZAR 19.146447
ZMK 9855.148044
ZMW 28.89489
ZWL 352.547703
  • BCC

    3.4200

    142.37

    +2.4%

  • NGG

    0.5600

    66.24

    +0.85%

  • SCS

    0.3100

    12.91

    +2.4%

  • BCE

    0.1600

    33.02

    +0.48%

  • CMSD

    0.1800

    24.95

    +0.72%

  • GSK

    -0.3800

    38.83

    -0.98%

  • CMSC

    0.1200

    24.71

    +0.49%

  • RBGPF

    1.7400

    61.23

    +2.84%

  • BTI

    0.0700

    35.18

    +0.2%

  • JRI

    0.0300

    13.25

    +0.23%

  • RIO

    0.3900

    67.23

    +0.58%

  • RYCEF

    0.0100

    7.01

    +0.14%

  • VOD

    -0.0900

    9.65

    -0.93%

  • AZN

    0.4800

    77.35

    +0.62%

  • RELX

    0.4700

    46.83

    +1%

  • BP

    -0.2300

    32.11

    -0.72%

Energy majors exaggerating green performance: analysis
Energy majors exaggerating green performance: analysis / Photo: Daniel LEAL - AFP/File

Energy majors exaggerating green performance: analysis

Energy majors are exaggerating their green credentials in public messaging while continuing to allocate the majority of new investment to oil and gas projects, according to an industry analysis released Thursday.

Text size:

Campaigners say this "significant misalignment" between communication strategies and business plans could allow five of the biggest privately-owned energy firms to continue to delay the decarbonisation needed to avoid the worst impacts of climate change.

Industry watchdog InfluenceMap analysed the content of more than 3,400 public communications from BP, Chevron, ExxonMobil, Shell and TotalEnergies in 2021, from press releases, speeches and company and CEO social media accounts.

They found that 60 percent of all messages contained at least one "green" claim -- such as emissions reduction targets, transitioning the energy mix, or promoting fossil gas as part of a clean energy solution.

These public communications were found to contrast with the five's planned capital expenditure for 2022, with just 12 percent of new investments earmarked for low-carbon activities.

"You can see this real difference between a high use of green claims in public communications versus this ongoing strategy to kind of undermine and block climate policy," report co-author and program manager Faye Holder told AFP.

She said the gap between what the majors advertised and what they were investing in was misleading the public as to their role in battling climate change.

"Based on the public communications, and particularly social media, it would be fair enough if you walked away with the impression that these companies are acting to solve climate change, because that's what you're hearing from them," she said.

- 'Climate disinformation' -

The analysis found that Shell had the largest disparity between its green talk and actual low-carbon investment.

InfluenceMap said that 70 percent of Shell's communications last year contained at least one green claim, compared with just 10 percent of planned investment in low-carbon activities this year.

A spokesman for Shell told AFP the major was already investing "billions of dollars in low-carbon energy".

"To help alter the mix of energy Shell sells, we need to grow these new businesses rapidly. That means letting our customers know through advertising or social media what lower-carbon solutions we offer now or are developing."

The analysis found that 62 percent of TotalEnergies' communications mentioned green activities, while it planned to allocate 25 percent of 2022 capital expenditure on low-carbon projects.

A TotalEnergies spokeswoman countered that 30 percent of the firm's investments are devoted to "decarbonised energy".

"Our public announcements policy reflects the transformation of TotalEnergies in a multi-energy company," she told AFP.

An ExxonMobil spokesman said it "continues to mitigate emissions from its operations and achieved its 2025 emission-reduction plans four years earlier than planned".

BP and Chevron did not respond to requests for comment.

The analysis found that overall the five corporations had spent $750 million on climate-related messaging last year alone.

Report co-author Ed Collins said that represented good business for the majors, as it was significantly cheaper than decarbonising their business models and would encourage governments to continue subsidising their products.

"The costs seem huge, but the investment is tiny in comparison to the potential reward in terms of favourable policy conditions and subsidisation of building assets," he said.

Some of the firms analysed plan to increase oil and gas production by 2026, something the analysts said would see their emissions "significantly overshoot" the International Energy Agency's recommended net-zero pathway.

Gwendoline Delbos-Corfield, a Greens member of the European Parliament, said Thursday's analysis proved that the firms studied were engaged in "climate disinformation".

"It shows the lengths oil and gas companies are willing to go to mislead citizens and protect their own interests."

(P.Werner--BBZ)