Berliner Boersenzeitung - Masks in class -- how damaging to child development?

EUR -
AED 3.824403
AFN 72.783669
ALL 98.225528
AMD 409.464261
ANG 1.86853
AOA 955.849322
ARS 1064.387711
AUD 1.664145
AWG 1.874215
AZN 1.769528
BAM 1.951341
BBD 2.093416
BDT 123.896861
BGN 1.952286
BHD 0.392649
BIF 3065.294954
BMD 1.041231
BND 1.408082
BOB 7.164627
BRL 6.332664
BSD 1.036831
BTN 88.144565
BWP 14.330251
BYN 3.393046
BYR 20408.117808
BZD 2.084137
CAD 1.497322
CDF 2988.331476
CHF 0.932314
CLF 0.037326
CLP 1029.933253
CNY 7.600257
CNH 7.607949
COP 4571.001897
CRC 523.104561
CUC 1.041231
CUP 27.592608
CVE 110.014643
CZK 25.124215
DJF 184.628074
DKK 7.457658
DOP 63.135717
DZD 140.371386
EGP 53.084848
ERN 15.618458
ETB 129.24454
FJD 2.41152
FKP 0.824636
GBP 0.82807
GEL 2.926165
GGP 0.824636
GHS 15.24117
GIP 0.824636
GMD 74.968838
GNF 8957.529568
GTQ 7.988744
GYD 216.914291
HKD 8.091022
HNL 26.318854
HRK 7.468649
HTG 135.640025
HUF 414.44462
IDR 16858.094479
ILS 3.784951
IMP 0.824636
INR 88.601952
IQD 1358.196146
IRR 43822.821093
ISK 145.095638
JEP 0.824636
JMD 162.219284
JOD 0.738439
JPY 163.034814
KES 134.683497
KGS 90.587188
KHR 4166.478445
KMF 485.34358
KPW 937.106868
KRW 1512.007243
KWD 0.320761
KYD 0.864025
KZT 544.505654
LAK 22693.139901
LBP 92844.823907
LKR 304.404352
LRD 188.179957
LSL 19.088078
LTL 3.074483
LVL 0.62983
LYD 5.094358
MAD 10.434853
MDL 19.097357
MGA 4891.820837
MKD 61.496935
MMK 3381.876049
MNT 3538.101105
MOP 8.300232
MRU 41.233769
MUR 48.781555
MVR 16.046221
MWK 1797.378204
MXN 20.905883
MYR 4.674608
MZN 66.538512
NAD 19.088078
NGN 1610.210968
NIO 38.15281
NOK 11.77626
NPR 141.031704
NZD 1.841224
OMR 0.400872
PAB 1.036831
PEN 3.860777
PGK 4.204392
PHP 60.972335
PKR 288.591389
PLN 4.256512
PYG 8084.524626
QAR 3.779662
RON 4.975999
RSD 116.979118
RUB 105.531204
RWF 1445.297097
SAR 3.912738
SBD 8.729213
SCR 14.520152
SDG 626.296741
SEK 11.493389
SGD 1.411039
SHP 0.824636
SLE 23.794301
SLL 21834.086132
SOS 592.545869
SRD 36.579493
STD 21551.369123
SVC 9.072267
SYP 2616.123123
SZL 19.083389
THB 35.54656
TJS 11.342479
TMT 3.654719
TND 3.30375
TOP 2.438663
TRY 36.671935
TTD 7.036919
TWD 34.038856
TZS 2498.953516
UAH 43.482929
UGX 3803.308389
USD 1.041231
UYU 46.244319
UZS 13367.451677
VES 53.598498
VND 26496.713159
VUV 123.61697
WST 2.876699
XAF 654.461375
XAG 0.035009
XAU 0.000396
XCD 2.813977
XDR 0.790893
XOF 654.461375
XPF 119.331742
YER 260.698065
ZAR 19.131335
ZMK 9372.319369
ZMW 28.693428
ZWL 335.275796
  • CMSC

    0.0200

    23.86

    +0.08%

  • SCS

    -0.5800

    11.74

    -4.94%

  • RIO

    -0.0900

    58.64

    -0.15%

  • NGG

    0.8200

    58.5

    +1.4%

  • GSK

    0.1700

    33.6

    +0.51%

  • CMSD

    0.0000

    23.56

    0%

  • BCE

    0.0500

    23.16

    +0.22%

  • BCC

    -0.2600

    122.75

    -0.21%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0100

    7.27

    -0.14%

  • BTI

    0.1131

    36.24

    +0.31%

  • AZN

    0.9100

    65.35

    +1.39%

  • RBGPF

    59.9600

    59.96

    +100%

  • JRI

    0.1100

    12.06

    +0.91%

  • BP

    0.1900

    28.6

    +0.66%

  • RELX

    -0.3100

    45.47

    -0.68%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    8.39

    +0.12%

Masks in class -- how damaging to child development?
Masks in class -- how damaging to child development?

Masks in class -- how damaging to child development?

Two years into the pandemic, concerns around the effect of masks on the linguistic, emotional and social development of children are taking center stage.

Text size:

In the United States, calls to lift mask mandates at school have multiplied in recent weeks, including within the scientific community, at a time when new cases of Covid-19 are plunging.

Scientific studies have shown that masks do indeed impact children's ability to recognize faces and emotions. As with adults, masks can also interfere with verbal communication. But experts are divided on the long-term effects on children's development.

- Learning language -

The first fear concerns the learning of language, which takes place in the first years of life. Children learn to speak through social interactions, and in particular look at the mouths of adults in order to dissect syllables.

This path being blocked, it seems logical to suppose a harmful effect.

"You do look at faces when you're learning to talk," Diane Paul, of the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) told AFP. "But it's not the only way."

Children also learn by listening to the voices and following the gestures and eye movements of those around them. Paul notes that those with visual impairment also learn to speak well -- and that masks are not worn permanently, for example at home.

"At least at this time, there aren't studies that have directly assessed the long term impact of speech and language development when young children interact with adults who wear masks," says the expert.

"But there are studies that demonstrate that children can tune into these different communication cues and gestures when an adult's mouth isn't visible."

A 2021 study demonstrated that infants were able to recognize unique words through a mask, just as well as without. But according to another, conducted in France, masks can interfere with learning to read among children with learning difficulties.

In general, research remains rare on the subject. But, says Paul, "I really do not see any cause for alarm."

According to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), "the limited available data indicate no clear evidence that masking impairs emotional or language development in children."

The agency recommends masking in public for those aged two and up, while the World Health Organization suggests the age of five.

- Social and emotional development -

But among psychiatrists, the story is a little different.

"More important is the emotional side," says Manfred Spitzer, who's also a specialist in cognitive neuroscience at the University of Ulm in Germany. He notes that the first thing lost with a mask is the sight of a smile.

"In educational settings, there is a lot of implicit feedback back and forth between teacher and child," he told AFP.

"If you impair this ongoing communication, you will certainly interfere with successful teaching."

Fears also relate to the ability to form social ties. Numerous studies have shown that masks make it more difficult to identify faces and emotions, including -- or even more -- among the youngest.

But conclusions about the consequences differ.

A study of children aged seven to 13, published in the journal PLOS One, confirmed that emotions (fear, sadness, anger) were less well identified when a person wore a mask -- but with similar results compared to wearing sunglasses.

It concluded that "masks are unlikely to dramatically impair children's social interactions in their everyday lives."

Yet other work, published in Frontiers in Psychology, has shown that performance in identifying the emotions of masked people dropped significantly between ages three and five, results that "suggest that we live in a time that may potentially affect the development of social and emotional reasoning," the authors said.

Carol Vidal, a psychiatrist at Johns Hopkins University, said that she's concerned at a societal level, though parents shouldn't panic.

Vidal is part of a group of medics and scholars called "Urgency of normal" calling for the lifting of compulsory masking at school, where it's hard to maintain the stringent use of masks anyway.

"I just think they're not necessary at this point in the pandemic, knowing what we know about the risks for kids in terms of Covid, and knowing that we all have access to vaccinations, and that if we're concerned about our health we can wear N95s (high-caliber masks)," she tells AFP.

It boils down to balancing risks and benefits, she stresses. The downsides of masks "might not be dramatic in the sense that you might not have effects right away, but I think we have to be careful," said Vidal.

(P.Werner--BBZ)