Berliner Boersenzeitung - Negotiating with Moscow would be capitulation: Ukraine presidency

EUR -
AED 4.033632
AFN 75.554639
ALL 98.772991
AMD 426.769718
ANG 1.987359
AOA 1013.613232
ARS 1071.533469
AUD 1.61591
AWG 1.97671
AZN 1.871252
BAM 1.955661
BBD 2.226442
BDT 131.77065
BGN 1.958126
BHD 0.413671
BIF 3199.173
BMD 1.098172
BND 1.431298
BOB 7.619459
BRL 5.992932
BSD 1.102722
BTN 92.528435
BWP 14.585965
BYN 3.608644
BYR 21524.172736
BZD 2.222642
CAD 1.491263
CDF 3152.852434
CHF 0.941709
CLF 0.036817
CLP 1015.897916
CNY 7.707466
CNH 7.796148
COP 4619.972186
CRC 571.959416
CUC 1.098172
CUP 29.10156
CVE 110.257177
CZK 25.371843
DJF 196.356067
DKK 7.460437
DOP 66.315295
DZD 146.42761
EGP 53.048236
ERN 16.472581
ETB 131.91484
FJD 2.429651
FKP 0.836323
GBP 0.836926
GEL 3.00942
GGP 0.836323
GHS 17.444762
GIP 0.836323
GMD 75.774264
GNF 9520.324478
GTQ 8.532395
GYD 230.693631
HKD 8.529514
HNL 27.419054
HRK 7.466484
HTG 145.389684
HUF 401.715553
IDR 17208.356468
ILS 4.188324
IMP 0.836323
INR 92.279785
IQD 1444.497505
IRR 46238.535747
ISK 148.978448
JEP 0.836323
JMD 174.237637
JOD 0.778059
JPY 163.312508
KES 142.249907
KGS 93.019347
KHR 4475.682425
KMF 493.024776
KPW 988.354248
KRW 1479.095448
KWD 0.336404
KYD 0.918935
KZT 532.542213
LAK 24349.272279
LBP 98745.393447
LKR 323.85702
LRD 212.8149
LSL 19.264533
LTL 3.242617
LVL 0.664274
LYD 5.258627
MAD 10.785735
MDL 19.346627
MGA 5050.641628
MKD 61.615628
MMK 3566.820073
MNT 3731.588673
MOP 8.817974
MRU 43.654902
MUR 51.054436
MVR 16.857357
MWK 1912.064328
MXN 21.173201
MYR 4.635938
MZN 70.177291
NAD 19.264533
NGN 1798.454863
NIO 40.577121
NOK 11.700809
NPR 148.045495
NZD 1.783123
OMR 0.42283
PAB 1.102722
PEN 4.107709
PGK 4.391688
PHP 62.203216
PKR 305.994888
PLN 4.317782
PYG 8595.390108
QAR 4.020515
RON 4.98296
RSD 117.010697
RUB 104.99255
RWF 1493.993993
SAR 4.125043
SBD 9.091451
SCR 16.483971
SDG 660.554542
SEK 11.385387
SGD 1.431581
SHP 0.836323
SLE 25.09027
SLL 23028.113751
SOS 630.155287
SRD 34.266988
STD 22729.944822
SVC 9.648315
SYP 2759.190222
SZL 19.256634
THB 36.545012
TJS 11.743567
TMT 3.854584
TND 3.373161
TOP 2.572033
TRY 37.608083
TTD 7.478469
TWD 35.455625
TZS 3004.786793
UAH 45.397479
UGX 4043.713075
USD 1.098172
UYU 46.116728
UZS 14049.003142
VEF 3978186.045782
VES 40.620775
VND 27201.722381
VUV 130.377195
WST 3.072096
XAF 655.910459
XAG 0.034122
XAU 0.000414
XCD 2.967865
XDR 0.820042
XOF 655.910459
XPF 119.331742
YER 274.876415
ZAR 19.192369
ZMK 9884.870451
ZMW 29.02794
ZWL 353.610961
  • RELX

    -0.3200

    46.29

    -0.69%

  • RBGPF

    58.9400

    58.94

    +100%

  • NGG

    -0.4700

    66.5

    -0.71%

  • RIO

    -0.1300

    69.7

    -0.19%

  • CMSC

    -0.0400

    24.7

    -0.16%

  • GSK

    0.4500

    38.82

    +1.16%

  • AZN

    -0.4600

    77.47

    -0.59%

  • BCC

    0.6100

    138.9

    +0.44%

  • SCS

    0.3500

    12.97

    +2.7%

  • VOD

    -0.0300

    9.66

    -0.31%

  • CMSD

    -0.0770

    24.813

    -0.31%

  • BP

    0.4200

    32.88

    +1.28%

  • RYCEF

    0.0000

    6.98

    0%

  • JRI

    -0.0200

    13.28

    -0.15%

  • BCE

    -0.1300

    33.71

    -0.39%

  • BTI

    0.1800

    35.29

    +0.51%

Negotiating with Moscow would be capitulation: Ukraine presidency
Negotiating with Moscow would be capitulation: Ukraine presidency / Photo: Genya SAVILOV - AFP

Negotiating with Moscow would be capitulation: Ukraine presidency

The West's attempts to persuade Ukraine to negotiate with Moscow, after a series of major military victories by Kiev, are "bizarre" and amount to asking for its capitulation, a key adviser to the Ukrainian presidency told AFP.

Text size:

"When you have the initiative on the battlefield, it's slightly bizarre to receive proposals like: 'you will not be able to do everything by military means anyway, you need to negotiate," said Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky's adviser Mykhaylo Podolyak.

This would mean that the country "that recovers its territories, must capitulate to the country that is losing," he added, during an interview with AFP at his office in the presidency building in Kyiv.

US media recently reported that some senior officials were beginning to encourage Ukraine to consider talks, which Zelensky has so far rejected without a prior withdrawal of Russian forces from all Ukrainian territory.

"There has to be a mutual recognition that military victory is probably in the true sense of the word maybe not achievable through military means," top US General Mark Milley said earlier this month, estimating that there is "a window of opportunity for negotiation".

According to Podolyak, Moscow has not made "any direct proposal" to Kiev for peace talks, preferring to transmit them through intermediaries and even raising the possibility of a ceasefire.

- Negotiating 'makes no sense' -

Kiev sees such talk as mere manoeuvring by the Kremlin to win some respite on the ground and prepare a new offensive.

"Russia doesn't want negotiations. Russia is conducting a communication campaign called 'negotiations'," the Ukraine presidential adviser said.

"It will simply stall for time. In the meantime, it will train its mobilised forces, find additional weapons" and fortify its positions," he warned.

Despite Russia's heavy military defeats in recent weeks, including Ukraine retaking the key southern city of Kherson, President Vladimir Putin still thinks "he can destroy Ukraine, this is his obsession" and negotiating with him "makes no sense", Podolyak argued.

The West cannot pressurise Ukraine into negotiations, he insisted.

"Our partners still think that it is possible to return to the pre-war era when Russia is a reliable partner".

Following massive Russian withdrawals from the Kyiv region in March, then from the Kharkiv region in the northeast in September, the liberation of Kherson this month marked a "fundamental" turning point in the conflict, according to Podolyak.

Spurred on by its string of military victories, Ukraine can "afford no pause" in its counter-offensive, despite the arrival of winter cold and snow that make the situation on the ground more difficult.

"Today, even a little pause just adds to the losses suffered by Ukraine," said the official.

- Longer range missiles -

Moscow has been shelling the country's energy infrastructure for weeks, plunging millions of homes into darkness.

The regions of Zaporizhzhia in southern Ukraine and Lugansk in the east are now the "key directions" for the army, Podolyak said, while refusing to speculate on the possibility of a military operation to retake the Crimean peninsula, which Moscow annexed back in 2014.

Ukrainian authorities are calling for an increase in Western arms deliveries, which is "very important" in winter," he added.

British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak used his first visit to Kyiv on Saturday to offer a major new air defence package, including 125 anti-aircraft guns.

"We still need 150 to 200 tanks, about 300 armoured vehicles," a hundred artillery systems, 50-70 multiple rocket launcher systems, including the formidable American HIMARS, of which Ukraine already has several units, as well as "10 to 15 anti-aircraft defence systems to close the sky," said Podolyak.

He also cited US ATACMS missiles, which have a range of 300 kilometres (185 miles). The range of the weapons currently available to Ukraine barely exceeds 80 kilometres.

For Podolyak, such missiles would "bring the end of the war closer" by allowing Ukraine to "destroy large Russian military depots" located deep in occupied areas which are currently inaccessible.

Kyiv "doesn't need" to attack military targets inside Russia, the adviser said.

"The war will end when we regain control of our borders and when Russia is afraid of Ukraine."

(U.Gruber--BBZ)