Berliner Boersenzeitung - Israeli film revisits alleged 1948 massacre of Palestinians

EUR -
AED 4.315254
AFN 81.668331
ALL 97.673389
AMD 450.90183
ANG 2.10293
AOA 1077.492447
ARS 1495.855073
AUD 1.782316
AWG 2.117384
AZN 1.999183
BAM 1.956131
BBD 2.372611
BDT 143.654914
BGN 1.955349
BHD 0.442824
BIF 3443.98005
BMD 1.175019
BND 1.50136
BOB 8.120477
BRL 6.487747
BSD 1.175104
BTN 101.498603
BWP 15.704724
BYN 3.845667
BYR 23030.368126
BZD 2.360429
CAD 1.603178
CDF 3394.629044
CHF 0.934945
CLF 0.028462
CLP 1116.561528
CNY 8.406108
CNH 8.404833
COP 4786.744513
CRC 593.202878
CUC 1.175019
CUP 31.137998
CVE 110.627949
CZK 24.547357
DJF 208.824479
DKK 7.46493
DOP 70.970439
DZD 152.102067
EGP 57.644307
ERN 17.625282
ETB 162.270348
FJD 2.629924
FKP 0.865959
GBP 0.870037
GEL 3.184097
GGP 0.865959
GHS 12.231928
GIP 0.865959
GMD 84.601692
GNF 10170.962422
GTQ 9.018564
GYD 245.854731
HKD 9.223539
HNL 30.962102
HRK 7.530934
HTG 154.206744
HUF 397.479556
IDR 19170.431427
ILS 3.923147
IMP 0.865959
INR 101.557284
IQD 1539.274604
IRR 49482.97416
ISK 142.176735
JEP 0.865959
JMD 188.141829
JOD 0.833049
JPY 173.019162
KES 152.167794
KGS 102.582313
KHR 4723.575567
KMF 491.748974
KPW 1057.52885
KRW 1612.572911
KWD 0.358581
KYD 0.97927
KZT 637.837905
LAK 25339.279986
LBP 105222.93163
LKR 354.670001
LRD 236.178726
LSL 20.703807
LTL 3.469524
LVL 0.710757
LYD 6.339243
MAD 10.56195
MDL 19.759427
MGA 5205.332841
MKD 61.574347
MMK 2466.171552
MNT 4218.844008
MOP 9.501429
MRU 46.789613
MUR 53.169202
MVR 18.09066
MWK 2040.421774
MXN 21.794225
MYR 4.952703
MZN 75.154159
NAD 20.574774
NGN 1800.422205
NIO 43.18206
NOK 11.898357
NPR 162.398164
NZD 1.947541
OMR 0.451798
PAB 1.175114
PEN 4.178401
PGK 4.853121
PHP 66.811221
PKR 335.1447
PLN 4.255387
PYG 8801.526437
QAR 4.277775
RON 5.068323
RSD 117.109395
RUB 93.118295
RWF 1691.439537
SAR 4.408151
SBD 9.735142
SCR 16.618216
SDG 705.59564
SEK 11.203075
SGD 1.501633
SHP 0.92338
SLE 26.967136
SLL 24639.560985
SOS 671.515781
SRD 42.994523
STD 24320.516432
STN 24.980899
SVC 10.281783
SYP 15277.579437
SZL 20.574819
THB 37.929542
TJS 11.163631
TMT 4.124316
TND 3.36731
TOP 2.752007
TRY 47.636392
TTD 7.986385
TWD 34.552578
TZS 3019.797783
UAH 49.095915
UGX 4216.731302
USD 1.175019
UYU 46.998151
UZS 15022.615492
VES 141.323505
VND 30709.115865
VUV 140.775827
WST 3.2299
XAF 656.070781
XAG 0.030057
XAU 0.000349
XCD 3.175547
XCG 2.117858
XDR 0.814624
XOF 655.660274
XPF 119.331742
YER 283.120242
ZAR 20.708566
ZMK 10576.60609
ZMW 27.407987
ZWL 378.355568
  • RIO

    -0.7900

    63.83

    -1.24%

  • CMSC

    0.0000

    22.43

    0%

  • SCU

    0.0000

    12.72

    0%

  • NGG

    -0.4200

    72.23

    -0.58%

  • BTI

    0.2500

    52.62

    +0.48%

  • CMSD

    -0.0400

    22.85

    -0.18%

  • RYCEF

    -0.2600

    13.24

    -1.96%

  • SCS

    -0.1700

    10.51

    -1.62%

  • BP

    -0.5800

    32.13

    -1.81%

  • GSK

    0.2000

    38.23

    +0.52%

  • RBGPF

    7.0000

    75

    +9.33%

  • VOD

    0.2200

    11.52

    +1.91%

  • AZN

    0.6800

    73.68

    +0.92%

  • RELX

    0.6200

    53.71

    +1.15%

  • JRI

    -0.0600

    13.15

    -0.46%

  • BCC

    -1.9200

    86.43

    -2.22%

  • BCE

    -0.1700

    24.43

    -0.7%

Israeli film revisits alleged 1948 massacre of Palestinians
Israeli film revisits alleged 1948 massacre of Palestinians

Israeli film revisits alleged 1948 massacre of Palestinians

Israeli director Alon Schwarz concedes he might face a backlash over his documentary on an alleged 1948 massacre of Palestinians, but says the Jewish state's citizens need "to understand our history".

Text size:

"Tantura", which premiered at the Sundance Film Festival last week, revisits a controversial episode from the war that raged during Israel's creation, in which more than 760,000 Palestinians fled or were forced from their homes.

Tantura was a coastal Mediterranean village in the northwest of what is now Israel, and the scene of fighting between Jewish and Arab forces in May of 1948.

The film in part focuses on Theodore Katz, who as a masters history student in the 1990s collected testimonies -- from ex-Israeli soldiers and Arab witnesses -- which indicated troops massacred unarmed Palestinians in Tantura outside the context of a battle.

Katz's paper initially earned top marks from the University of Haifa but became a source of national controversy after his findings were picked up by Israeli media in 2000.

Veterans of the Israeli unit that fought in Tantura, the Alexandroni Brigade, sued Katz for defamation and he ultimately issued a retraction, a move he now regrets.

Katz is a main character in Schwarz's documentary, which includes extensive testimony from former Alexandroni Brigade soldiers and witnesses, and supports claims of a massacre at Tantura.

Schwarz told AFP that he understands the film could face criticism but said he believed that a new generation of Israelis is more willing to discuss difficult episodes in the nation's history.

"On the one hand, I'm afraid people will go after me but on the other hand, Israel is going through a change," he said. "I am a Zionist. I am for Jews having their own state but I think it is critical for us to understand our history."

- 'It happened' -

Some soldiers interviewed in "Tantura" deny that any Palestinians were killed outside the context of the battle for the town.

Others unequivocally confirm that Israeli forces shot Arabs dead away from the combat zone, but estimates on the numbers potentially killed vary widely.

"It was silenced," one veteran, Yossef Diamant, says in the film. "It was horrifying... I don't want to talk about it, but it happened."

Israel's army declined to comment on the film or the allegations of a massacre, but Schwarz told AFP he received "helpful, straightforward and professional" assistance from the military during his research.

In addition to witness testimony, notably from Palestinians, "Tantura" includes expert analysis on how changes in the ground level before and after the conflict suggest human manipulation of the soil consistent with the digging of a mass grave.

The film concludes that several Palestinians were likely buried under what is now a parking lot next to the popular Dor beach.

- 'Deal with our past' -

After the film's release, the Palestinian foreign ministry, based in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, called for "an international commission of inquiry" into the "crimes and massacres" allegedly committed by Israeli forces.

In an editorial, Israel's left-wing Haaretz newspaper called for "an investigative task force" to probe the events in Tantura.

Schwarz said that he endured "a personal psychological roller coaster" in investigating the events.

"I am this guy who thought I had a grip on our historical reality but I actually grew up on the myth" about the moral purity of the Israeli state, he said.

When it comes to the conflict with the Palestinians, he said, "telling ourselves a story that there wasn't a people here before is not helpful".

"That is the founding myth of the nation and I think we need to get real and mature as a society."

Adam Raz, an Israeli historian who assisted in the film's production, told AFP that resistance to discussing what happened at Tantura was ultimately not in the national interest.

Jews and Palestinians will live alongside each other "now and in 100 years", said Raz, who works at Akevot, an organisation that specialises in researching state archives.

"If we want to go forward towards reconciliation, we need to deal with our past."

(F.Schuster--BBZ)